Teams 
 | ||
| Year | All-Stars (Pos.) | |
| ||
| 2009 | Prince Fielder (1B), Ryan Braun (LF), TREVOR HOFFMAN (P) | |
| ||
| 2008 | Ryan Braun (OF), Corey Hart (OF), Ben Sheets (P) | |
| ||
| 2007 | Prince Fielder (1B), Francisco Cordero (P), Ben Sheets (P), J.J. Hardy (SS) | |
| ||
| 2006 | Carlos Lee (LF), Derrick Turnbow (P), Chris Capuano (P) | |
| ||
| 2005 | Carlos Lee (LF), Ned Yost (Coach) | |
| ||
| 2004 | Danny Kolb (P), Ben Sheets (P) | |
| ||
| 2003 | Richie Sexson (1B), Geoff Jenkins (OF) | |
| ||
| 2002 | Richie Sexson (1B), Jose Hernandez (SS) | |
| ||
| 2001 | Ben Sheets (P) | |
| ||
| 2000 | Bob Wickman (P) | |
| ||
| 1999 | Jeromy Burnitz (OF), Dave Nilsson (C) | |
| ||
| 1998 | Fernando Vina (2B) | |
| ||
| 1997 | Jeff Cirillo (3B) | |
| ||
| 1996 | Greg Vaughn (OF) | |
| ||
| 1995 | Kevin Seitzer (3B) | |
| ||
| 1994 | Ricky Bones (P) | |
| ||
| 1993 | Greg Vaughn (OF) | |
| ||
| 1992 | Paul Molitor (1B) | |
| ||
| 1991 | Paul Molitor (3B) | |
| ||
| 1990 | Dave Parker (DH) | |
| ||
| 1989 | Dan Plesac (P) | |
| ||
| 1988 | Paul Molitor (2B), Dan Plesac (P) | |
| ||
| 1987 | Dan Plesac (P) | |
| ||
| 1986 | Teddy Higuera (P) | |
| ||
| 1985 | Cecil Cooper (1B), Paul Molitor (3B) | |
| ||
| 1984 | Jim Sundberg (C) | |
| ||
| 1983 | Cecil Cooper (1B), Ben Oglivie (OF), Ted Simmons (C), Robin Yount (SS) | |
| ||
| 1982 | Cecil Cooper (1B), Ben Oglivie (OF), Robin Yount (SS) | |
| ||
| 1981 | Ted Simmons (C), Gorman Thomas (OF), Rollie Fingers (P) | |
| ||
| 1980 | Cecil Cooper (1B), Paul Molitor (2B), Ben Oglivie (OF), Robin Yount (SS) | |
| ||
| 1979 | Cecil Cooper (1B) | |
| ||
| 1978 | Larry Hisle (OF), Don Money (2B), Lary Sorensen (P) | |
| ||
| 1977 | Don Money (3B), Jim Slaton (P) | |
| ||
| 1976 | Don Money (3B), Bill Travers (P) | |
| ||
| 1975 | Henry Aaron (OF), George Scott (1B) | |
| ||
| 1974 | Don Money (3B), Darrell Porter (C) | |
| ||
| 1973 | Davey May (OF), Jim Colborn (P) | |
| ||
| 1972 | Ellie Rodriguez (C) | |
| ||
| 1971 | Marty Pattin (P) | |
| ||
| 1970 | Tommy Harper (3B) | |
| ||
